My son was not quite three when he first started telling us he was a boy. He had been assigned female at birth, which of course seemed like a fairly reasonable assumption at the time. At first my wife and I chalked it up to one of those “kids say the darndest things” comments. When he kept saying it, we thought maybe he was telling us he preferred doing boy things, kind of a tomboy.
But that wasn’t it either. He didn’t say “I want to be a boy.” He didn’t say “I want to be like a boy.” He said, “I am a boy.” And he kept saying it, patiently and insistently, with the directness very small children bring to the things that matter most.
Back then we hadn’t even considered that he could be transgender. The only transgender people we knew were adults. But Jacq knew. He didn’t have the word for it, and he didn’t need it. He was telling us that someone had gotten something important wrong about him. He didn’t want to be a boy. He was one.
This episode is about what I didn’t know. And what it took to find out.
My son was certain. I wasn’t, at least not yet. I’d never believed transgender people were confused or disordered or mistaken. I was something simpler and far more common: a man who had never had a reason to think carefully about this.
Gender had always looked to me like a settled question. I hadn’t weighed any evidence to get there. I’d just never had a reason to look.
What my son was telling me, at not quite three, was that I’d been working from a flawed assumption, one I’d never thought to test. And I had spent my whole career being trained for exactly this situation.
I’m an engineer. For more than three decades I’ve designed aerospace systems that have to operate in harsh places I can’t directly observe, under conditions I can’t fully predict.
Ignorance isn’t the cardinal sin in my discipline. Every engineer works in conditions of partial ignorance; that’s what makes the work hard and interesting. The cardinal sin, the failure mode that ends careers and, in less forgiving metaphors, brings bridges down, is pretending you aren’t ignorant. It’s applying certainty you haven’t earned to a system that will eventually, under some condition you didn’t anticipate, test that certainty and find it wanting.
When the model doesn’t fit the data, you revise the model.
My three-year-old son was data I hadn’t anticipated. I had two choices: force him into the model I’d inherited, or update the model. The engineering training made one of those obviously correct. The fear—and I won’t pretend the fear wasn’t there—made it feel harder than it sounds.
The fear deserves naming, because it was real, and because I think any parent listening will recognize it. I wasn’t afraid Jacq was wrong about who he was. His certainty was transparent and total, the honest certainty of direct experience. What I was afraid of was what it would mean for him in the world: the cruelty he might run into, and the systems that hadn’t been designed with him in mind.
That fear is different from the manufactured fear I’ll spend much of this series examining, the kind political movements cultivate and deploy for their own purposes. Mine was the ancient, specific fear of a parent, that the world will be harder for your child than your love can fix.
Here’s what I learned about that fear. It’s a terrible guide. The fear itself is perfectly rational; the trouble is that it points in the wrong direction. The fear says to protect your child by fitting him into the world as it is. The evidence says something else entirely.
Children supported in their authentic identities, affirmed by the people who love them, and given the care medicine has developed for them, thrive. The research on that is now substantial and consistent across countries, study designs, and patient populations. The fear wanted me to make my son smaller. The evidence wanted me to make the world bigger.
The evidence won.
Because alongside the fear was something else. I was urgently curious. I wanted to understand, and yes, understanding was a professional obligation, but the real reason was that my child was showing me something I’d never seen before, and it was extraordinary.
How does a child still a couple of years away from kindergarten know, with that kind of clarity and consistency, that something about their identity is fundamentally off? What does the developmental science actually say? What has been studied? What do the clinicians who’ve worked with hundreds of these kids find?
I started reading. I called physicians. I found researchers. And most important, I found people whose lived experiences matched our own: other families of young trans kids, and trans adults who had been where my son was. The relief was palpable. We weren’t crazy, and we certainly weren’t alone.
I learned that Jacq wasn’t an anomaly. Gender identity typically crystallizes in children between three and five years old. Children who are consistent, persistent, and insistent about their gender identity turn out, in long-term follow-up research, to have been right about themselves from the beginning almost universally. There was a substantial and growing body of evidence, and when I read it without the filter of what I expected to find, it was coherent and clear.
Somewhere in that process—somewhere between the first phone call and the third research paper—the fear began to lose its grip. The world hadn’t gotten any safer. But knowledge is its own kind of courage. When you understand what you’re dealing with, you can make decisions grounded in evidence instead of managed by anxiety. You can be useful, in the engineering sense of the word.
Jacq and I took this journey together, the way the best journeys between parents and children happen: him leading, me following, both of us learning the terrain as we went. He didn’t need me to already know. He needed me to be willing to find out. And that willingness, the genuine, sometimes humbling willingness to discover that the world is more complicated than you’d understood, turned out to be the most important thing I had to offer him.
I’m using the word curious deliberately, because the change it names is a big one. The science of human development, the neuroscience of gender identity, the fact that a child not yet three can know himself in a way his environment hasn’t caught up to: these are genuinely fascinating things. I went in afraid and came out curious—hardly the most poetic transformation, but in my experience one of the most useful.
Children arrive as themselves, and never as blank slates waiting to be written on. Partially formed, still becoming, finding their footing, yes. But always themselves, with inner lives running on their own logic, their own perceptions of what’s real, their own needs that may or may not match the ones you were ready for.
The part of a parent’s job that doesn’t get talked about honestly enough is being a student. You’re a teacher, a guide, a standard-setter, sure, but you’re also a student of this specific child in this specific moment. That means sitting in genuine uncertainty. Performing uncertainty doesn’t count, and neither does tolerating it until you can get back to certainty. It means actually accepting that you don’t know, and getting curious about what you might learn.
I’ve come to believe that’s a skill for citizenship as much as for parenthood. And we aren’t cultivating it nearly well enough.
In the spring of 2016, another parent forced our family to go public. This parent was running for a school board seat and had apparently decided that the existence of a transgender child in the district was a political asset for their campaign. I sat down that night and wrote a response. It began with these words.
Hello, world. I’m the dad of a trans kid.
I was defending my son, but I was doing more than that. I was making public, for the first time, everything I’d learned over the preceding years. Everything Jacq had been patient enough to show me. Everything the science said clearly and the false certainty of the attacks was choosing to ignore. Here we are. Here is what is real. Here is what the evidence shows. Here is what it means to follow it honestly.
Once you know what you know, you can’t unknow it. Once you’ve followed the evidence to where it actually leads, pretending it points somewhere else takes a kind of dishonesty that an engineer—or a parent—can’t sustain.
That dishonesty is why this series keeps coming back to the difference between evidence and authority. I’m agnostic. I don’t know whether God exists, and I arrived at that honest uncertainty through genuine reflection, not indifference. I’ve found real wisdom in religious traditions, and some of my most committed allies in this fight have been people of deep faith.
The argument I’m making is more specific, and more limited, than “religion is the problem.” The argument is that faith is not fact. A sincerely held belief is a different thing from an empirically verifiable claim, and confusing the two, specifically when it comes to governing, has costs that fall most heavily on the most vulnerable.
Nobody has to abandon their faith for this. What I’m asking for is an agreement about jurisdiction: the laws governing everyone should be grounded in evidence everyone can, in principle, evaluate. I think that’s a modest ask. Apparently it’s also a radical one, which tells us something important about where we are.
There’s a framework I’ll come back to in a later episode, the journalist Thomas Friedman’s observation that curiosity combined with passion outperforms raw intelligence. A person genuinely driven to understand something will, in the end, know more about it than a merely smart person who stopped asking questions. The personal version is simpler. The moment I stopped trying to fit my son into what I thought I knew, and started letting him teach me, was the moment I became actually useful to him. The same principle, I’m arguing throughout this series, applies to every domain where manufactured certainty is doing damage right now.
Engineers know this: when the model doesn’t fit the data, you revise the model. The question in front of us, as a democracy, is whether we’re willing to do the same.
I write as the father of a transgender son. As an engineer trained in the discipline of honest uncertainty. As an agnostic who has made peace with not knowing, and who believes that peace, that willingness to stay open to what the evidence shows, is intellectual integrity rather than weakness. And as a later-life advocate who came to this work gradually, reluctantly even—because my son needed me to.
If this series carries a single hope, it’s that you won’t have to arrive the way I did: late, and only because the cost of not arriving had become unbearable. The willingness to take a worldview apart and rebuild it can be practiced earlier, and on purpose, long before a crisis forces it. I’m asking you to be better at this than I was.
Hello, world. This is what I’ve learned.
Sign up on this site to receive updates on the soon-to-be-published book, “Fear Me Not: The Power of Curiosity to Heal a World Addicted to Certainty.” If podcasts are your thing, please check out the podcast series of the same name.


