This episode is about coalition—and it starts with a hard admission. The people whose manufactured certainty has been weaponized against my son aren’t, on the whole, people I find easy to approach with generosity. I’m not writing this from some serene magnanimity. I’m writing it with the practical awareness that we won’t find a solution unless we find common ground.
The coalition has to be built on a shared commitment to evidence, to democratic norms, and to the dignity of every person. It has to include people whose faith and political ideologies we don’t share. A faith coalition, in fact, is essential to finding that common ground.
The most common objection I hear to the argument I’ve been making goes something like this. You expect people to leave their religious convictions at the door when they enter a public debate, and that simply can’t be done.
Let me take that objection head on, because I think it obscures what I’m arguing. I’m not asking religious people to leave their convictions at the door. I’m not asking them to pretend their faith doesn’t shape their moral intuitions, or their sense of what their community owes its most vulnerable members. I’m asking them to do what the best thinkers in every tradition have understood is required: when public policy and legislation is at stake, arguments have to be backed up with logic and reason, and a person’s strongly held beliefs can’t stand in for that.
Religious thought knows this distinction well. It sits at the center of the most sophisticated religious political philosophy in the American tradition.
John Courtney Murray, the Jesuit theologian who shaped the Second Vatican Council’s Declaration on Religious Freedom, argued that a pluralistic democracy requires its citizens to justify their political claims in terms accessible to all citizens, and not only to those who share their faith. Reinhold Niebuhr, the Protestant theologian who shaped American public theology for most of the twentieth century, was just as insistent. The proper role of religion in public life, he argued, was to supply the moral seriousness and the critique of power that public life requires, rather than to impose particular theological conclusions on people who don’t share the theology.
You can believe, privately, that your tradition is the one true path. That’s your right. But when you walk into a legislature, you have to offer your neighbor reasons your neighbor can evaluate critically and universally, whether they share your faith or not.
Nobody here is arguing religion out of public life. The argument is about the form its presence should take. These are calls for the kind of religion that speaks to the conscience of the powerful on behalf of the vulnerable, the prophetic tradition, rather than the kind that speaks on behalf of the powerful to suppress the claims of the vulnerable. The kind of religion practiced by Black churches that embrace the social gospel, and by the welcoming and affirming congregations and synagogues, the ones that manufactured certainty tends to erase.
The question I’m putting to religious communities right now is which of those traditions they’re choosing. And the prophetic tradition is no marginal thing. It’s the Black churches organizing voter registration in states restricting the vote. The mainline communities offering sanctuary to immigrants. The UCC congregations declaring themselves open and affirming to LGBTQ families. The Jewish communities organizing legal aid for transgender people whose rights are being curtailed. These are substantial communities, and they represent a genuine theological tradition that manufactured certainty about religion and politics tends to erase.
I want to tell you about a specific conversation I had in Saline, Michigan. Saline is a small city in Washtenaw County, predominantly white, predominantly middle class, with a significant evangelical Christian community. In 2019 and 2020, a series of incidents in the Saline Area Schools, racist language directed at Black students, LGBTQ students reporting hostile environments, produced a community conversation that was contentious and difficult. I participated in some of it.
What I saw in Saline was the full range of responses to the evidence. People who denied the incidents added up to a systemic problem. People who acknowledged the incidents but resisted the conclusions about structural factors. People who engaged honestly and arrived at conclusions they hadn’t held before. And people, some of them among the most committed Christians in the community, who brought their faith explicitly to the question and arrived, through that faith, at a commitment to fairness and belonging more durable than anything secular organizing alone could have produced.
The lesson I took from Saline isn’t that religion is the answer, or that secular organizing is insufficient. The lesson is that the coalition capable of addressing manufactured certainty has to be broad enough to include people who arrive at the same commitments by different routes, and that dismissing the religious routes is both theologically arrogant and politically self-defeating.
There is, within Christianity itself, a rich tradition theologians call apophatic, or negative theology, which approaches God by acknowledging what God exceeds rather than by making affirmations about what God is. It runs through Jewish mysticism and Islamic Sufism as well. Many of the deepest spiritual thinkers in the world’s major religious traditions have understood that authentic faith requires something very close to what I’m calling the embrace of uncertainty. I have no quarrel with that faith. My quarrel is with the certainty that has been politically and institutionally engineered to maintain hierarchies of power. That kind of certainty is religious tradition corrupted, and a long way from its best.
The Black Freedom Movement is, for me, the most powerful demonstration there is of what happens when people of faith insist on that distinction. Ella Baker. Martin Luther King Jr., Coretta Scott King, and their children. John Lewis. Rosa Parks. Bayard Rustin. Fannie Lou Hamer. Andrew Young. The Rev. Dr. Pauli Murray. Jesse Jackson. These were deeply religious people, and their faith was the engine of a commitment to human dignity that was at the same time fully compatible with democratic pluralism and the scientific spirit.
King’s vision of the Beloved Community (a world in which, as he put it, “Our loyalties must transcend our race, our tribe, our class, and our nation”) is nothing a theocrat would say. It’s the vision of someone who had internalized the uncertainty that authentic faith demands: that your own tribe is not, in fact, the final measure of moral worth.
Coretta Scott King understood that the principle didn’t yield at the edge of any group’s comfort. The same dignity that insisted on the equality of Black Americans logically required the equality of LGBTQ Americans. She was right.
Here’s something I’ve learned after years in this fight. The communities most capable of building genuine coalitions across difference tend to share a specific quality. Call it what the journalist Thomas Friedman calls it: a high curiosity quotient. They hold their convictions with real moral seriousness while staying open to the evidence that arrives through the lives of people different from themselves. And it’s no coincidence that the congregations most likely to stand alongside transgender families are also the ones with the longest traditions of theological inquiry, of wrestling with the text rather than deferring to it.
Curiosity and solidarity turn out to be related. When you’re genuinely curious about another human being, when you approach their life as evidence to be taken seriously rather than a problem to be solved by a pre-existing doctrine, coalition becomes possible. When you’re not, no amount of organizing can manufacture it.
And the welcoming church, at its best, knows something purely secular movements sometimes don’t. For millions of Americans, the language of justice is most powerfully spoken in a religious register. The Letter from Birmingham Jail is a political document and a theological one at the same time: its appeal to a law higher than human law, its indictment of the white church’s cowardice, its insistence that the moral universe has a direction. Scientific Rebellion needs both languages. It needs the rigor of evidence and the fire of prophetic witness.
I’ve spent years trying to find common ground, and I’ve learned some things about what works and what doesn’t. Leading with the argument doesn’t work. When you approach someone whose political and religious identity is organized around manufactured certainty with a stack of evidence that contradicts their certainties, what you trigger is a threat response, and no conversation happens. The person doesn’t hear your evidence. They hear an attack on their identity. They respond with defensiveness, dismissiveness, or anger, and the evidence, however compelling, never gets processed. It gets rejected at the gate.
Leading with the relationship works. The most consequential conversations I’ve had about my family have been with people I already had some relationship with (neighbors, colleagues, relatives), never with strangers at political rallies. Those people got the chance to encounter my son as a person they already, to some degree, cared about, rather than as a political symbol. When someone already cares about you, the evidence of your humanity arrives differently. It doesn’t have to argue its way past the amygdala. It’s already in.
That’s why visibility matters. It’s why pride parades and public testimony and books like this one matter. They don’t change everyone’s mind. What they do is make it possible for people who are already in relationship with LGBTQ people to integrate that knowledge with their political choices. The research on this is consistent. Knowing an LGBTQ person personally is among the most reliable predictors of support for LGBTQ rights. The relationship precedes the evidence, and the relationship makes the evidence receivable.
The same principle applies to race and to every other form of dehumanization. The civil rights movement’s most powerful strategic insight went beyond the legal briefs, essential as those were. It was the decision to make the suffering of Black Americans visible to white Americans in ways that couldn’t be dismissed, to make the evidence of shared humanity impossible to ignore for people who were already, at some level, capable of recognizing it.
The people who aren’t capable of recognizing it won’t be reached by visibility or evidence or relationship. They’re anchored in a certainty that recognizing that shared humanity would destroy. They’re a minority. The strategy of Scientific Rebellion can’t be aimed primarily at persuading them. It has to be aimed at activating the much larger number of people who are already, somewhere, capable of recognizing the shared humanity they’re being asked to deny.
Those people exist. In most polls they’re a majority. They oppose book bans. They support access to medical care. They believe people should be treated with dignity regardless of gender identity or race. But for the most part they aren’t activated, and that’s the gap Scientific Rebellion exists to close.
The Poor People’s Campaign, relaunched by Reverend William Barber and Reverend Liz Theoharis in 2018, is one of the most significant attempts to build exactly the kind of coalition I’m describing. It’s broad-based. It explicitly connects racial justice, economic justice, LGBTQ equality, immigrant rights, and environmental justice as parts of a single moral and political project, grounded in both prophetic faith and empirical evidence. Its analysis is that these aren’t separate issues at all. They’re expressions of the same underlying structure: the use of manufactured certainty about who deserves rights to maintain hierarchies that benefit the few at the expense of the many.
Barber has documented, in The Third Reconstruction, the long history of interracial, interfaith coalitions in the American South that challenged the racial hierarchy well before the civil rights movement, coalitions white Christian nationalism worked hard to suppress. That history is itself a resource. It shows the alliances Scientific Rebellion needs have precedents. They’ve been built before, and they can be built again. The Moral Monday movement Barber led in North Carolina brought thousands of people to the state capitol every Monday for months, representing religious communities, LGBTQ organizations, labor unions, civil rights groups, and environmental advocates, and it demonstrated that fusion politics can be built in practice and not only in theory. It didn’t win every battle. But it changed the politics of a state Christian nationalism had claimed as its own.
And I want to describe the actual organizing concretely. The manufactured certainty movement succeeds, in large part, because it’s organized at the local level in ways most people don’t notice until the consequences have already landed. School board elections in most American communities draw turnout of less than twenty percent of registered voters. Candidates backed by Moms for Liberty and aligned organizations have flipped school boards in dozens of communities by organizing a few hundred votes in elections most people didn’t know were happening.
The response is difficult, but it isn’t complicated. More people have to show up. Run for school board, or recruit someone who understands the evidence on curricula that include LGBTQ people and history. Attend the legislative hearings, because when the only people who testify on a bill restricting gender-affirming care are affiliated with that movement, lawmakers hear one side of the evidence.
The other side has been organizing at the school-board and statehouse level for fifty years. They understand that the daily experience of a transgender child in a public school gets decided in a room of nine people on a Tuesday night, and that the legal architecture constraining those nine people for the next generation gets decided in Senate confirmation votes the public mostly doesn’t watch. They understand both ends of that pipeline. Everyone who opposes them needs to understand both ends too.
None of this is glamorous. But the decisions that determine the daily experience of real children get made by real people in actual rooms at actual times. Scientific Rebellion is the commitment to be in those rooms. We won’t find common ground if we’re not there.
I know what that looks like, because I watched it happen in my own school district. In 2019, the Dexter Community Schools district in my hometown was working through the I Am Jazz controversy and the broader question of how to support LGBTQ students. The administration didn’t retreat from the commitment it had made. But it also understood that the community held people with deeply different views, and that the path forward required finding language that could hold more of the community than the language of culture war could.
What eventually emerged, through many meetings and much difficulty, was a framework built around two principles instead of an ideology, two principles almost no parent, whatever their theological convictions, could reject. The safety of every child. And the dignity of every student. Nobody was asked to approve of every identity or to celebrate every family configuration. Just the commitment that every child would be safe at school, and that no child would be subjected to humiliation, harassment, or exclusion based on who they are.
That’s common ground, and it’s not nothing. It doesn’t resolve the theological disagreements. It doesn’t ask people to abandon their certainty about what God designs. It asks them to agree that whatever their certainty, it doesn’t authorize the harm of children in their community. And it asks the school to be the institution that protects children from that harm, by maintaining the basic conditions under which all children can learn rather than by deciding theological questions.
It’s a limited victory. It doesn’t protect transgender children in states where the law has been weaponized against them. It doesn’t change the minds of people who still believe my son’s identity is disordered. But it protected my son, in his school, during the years when he most needed protection. And it did that by finding language that spoke to the values of people who didn’t share my theology or my politics. That’s what common ground looks like. Nobody has to agree. People coexist under shared principles that don’t come from any particular theology. In the oldest sense of the word, that’s democracy.
Sign up on this site to receive updates on the soon-to-be-published book, “Fear Me Not: The Power of Curiosity to Heal a World Addicted to Certainty.” If podcasts are your thing, please check out the podcast series of the same name.


