The Certainty Gap

Episode Seven

This episode is about a gap. The enormous, exhausting gap between the world as it is, which is complex, uncertain, and demanding, and the world as we wish it were: simple, certain, easy.

Every movement that sells manufactured certainty lives in that gap. I want to talk about the one that currently controls one of the two major political parties in the United States, and about how to talk to the people it has recruited.

Start with the salesman. In this context Donald Trump is no aberration. He’s a perfect fit. Trump’s genius, and it’s a form of genius, however malign, is his complete indifference to the truth combined with his utter mastery of emotional certainty. His followers don’t love him because they believe every claim he makes. Many of them know perfectly well that he lies constantly. They love him because in a world of disorienting ambiguity, he speaks with absolute conviction. His certainty is a product, and his base buys it because they need it, because the alternative, accepting the complexity of a pluralistic, changing world, genuinely frightens them.

I don’t say that to condescend. The fear is real. What I want to know is whether the false certainty Trump offers actually makes anything better, or whether it just redirects the anxiety outward, onto immigrants, transgender people, Black Americans, scientists, anyone who can be cast as the source of the problem. The historical record on that question is clear. Manufactured certainty about the source of social anxiety has never resolved the anxiety. All it has ever done is provide license for violence.

I see Trump at a rally and I think, he’s a symptom. The problem is the gap. He found that gap, he climbed into it, and he built his entire political career inside it.

The tragedy is the size of the gap, far more than any one man. We have, as a society, done such a poor job of making uncertainty livable that a significant portion of the electorate is willing to pay almost any price for someone who will take it away, even a price that includes the people the false certainty scapegoats.

The movement that put him there has a name, and the name is being used, on all sides, in ways that make the conversation harder than it needs to be. In the fall of 2023, Amanda Tyler, the executive director of the Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty, offered what I think is the cleanest working definition. Christian nationalism is “the belief that America is defined by Christianity and that the government should keep it that way.”

That definition is useful because of what it implies about the nature of the claim. The claim concerns the proper relationship between government and religion, and it says nothing about the private religious convictions of American citizens. It’s a claim about power. It comes dressed in the language of faith, but its content is political: who gets to define the nation’s identity, and who gets excluded from full membership in it.

Tyler is careful about the language. “The Christian in Christian nationalism,” she says, “is more about identity than religion, and carries with it assumptions about nativism, white supremacy, authoritarianism, patriarchy, and militarism.” Christian nationalism is a political movement that uses Christian identity as its vehicle, rather than a religious movement that got mixed up in politics. Understanding that is the precondition for confronting it without being accused of bigotry against Christians, many of whom, in fact, are some of its most clear-eyed critics.

I have no quarrel with the Christian faith of my neighbors. The UCC congregations that affirm LGBTQ families. The Black churches that have been the spine of every freedom struggle in this country. The Catholic nuns who run homeless shelters. The Jewish synagogues that fight for immigrant rights. None of them are the target, and in many cases they’re partners in the coalition I’m trying to describe. My argument is with a specific political movement that has clothed itself in Christian language, and whose actual agenda is the reorganization of American democracy around the certainties of one tribe.

Kristin Kobes Du Mez, in her book Jesus and John Wayne, has done the work of tracing how we got here. She documents how decades of evangelical cultural production, the books, the music, the conferences, the parenting advice, the models of masculinity, worked to construct a version of Christianity centered on power, dominance, and the subordination of women. The Jesus that came out of this process was less Prince of Peace than warrior king. As Mike Johnson, who became Speaker of the House in 2023, preached to a Shreveport congregation: “We serve the Lion of Judah, not some sort of namby-pamby little king.” The Jesus of the Gospels consistently puts the vulnerable ahead of the powerful and refuses the role of political messiah even when it’s pressed on him. The warrior Christ is a construction.

Katherine Stewart, in The Power Worshippers, provides the organizational anatomy: a worldwide network of evangelical and like-minded religious organizations, funded by a dark web of extraordinarily wealthy conservative families, operating through hundreds of think tanks, legal organizations, lobbying groups, and media operations. This network has been working for decades to place its people in positions of power at every level of American government, and it has done so as an explicit, documented goal rather than a byproduct of political engagement. Stewart’s conclusion is that the movement is best understood as a political operation that presents itself as a religious one.

Surveys by the Public Religion Research Institute show that a majority of Republicans (55%) qualify as Christian-nationalism adherents or sympathizers. The movement includes card-carrying white nationalists, but it extends well beyond them. Most of its members are, in their daily lives, perfectly ordinary people: churchgoing, family-oriented, genuinely motivated by the desire to live according to their faith. What the movement offers them is exactly what the fear-of-uncertainty framework predicts they would most need, a clear and absolute certainty about who they are, who belongs to their community, and what the world ought to look like. The anxiety of living in a rapidly changing, demographically transforming, economically precarious America is real, and the certainty on offer is potent.

Project 2025, the thousand-page Heritage Foundation transition plan, is the most explicit roadmap yet published for what a fully Christian nationalist American government would look like. It proposes replacing fifty thousand career civil servants with political loyalists, removing independence from the Department of Justice, eliminating the Department of Education, rolling back civil rights protections for LGBTQ Americans, and banning gender-affirming care at the federal level. Kevin Roberts, the Heritage president, declared in July 2024: “We are in the process of the second American Revolution, which will remain bloodless if the left allows it to be.” Nobody talks like that about democratic governance. The condition for bloodlessness is placed on the people being revolutionized against, and never on the people doing the revolutionizing. That’s the grammar of a coup.

There’s a 2024 sermon Trump gave at the National Religious Broadcasters Convention in Nashville that should ring familiar to anyone who has studied the civil rights era. Trump said, “Remember, every communist regime throughout history has tried to stamp out the churches, just like every fascist regime has tried to co-opt them and control them, and, in America, the radical left is trying to do both. They want to tear down crosses where they can and cover them up with social justice flags, but no one will be touching the cross of Christ under the Trump administration, I swear to you.”

That argument is old. It’s the precise argument FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover deployed against Martin Luther King Jr.: the conflation of social justice with communism, used to discredit, neutralize, and ultimately destroy the leaders of movements that threatened the existing order. After King’s assassination, Coretta Scott King devoted the rest of her life to insisting on the connection Hoover had tried to destroy, the connection between the social gospel and full human equality, including, explicitly, equality for the LGBTQ community. The target changes with each generation. The weapon stays the same.

The consequences of this rhetoric go well beyond rhetoric. Violence against transgender and Black communities rises as white Christian nationalist language intensifies. Transgender individuals, particularly Black and Native American trans women, experience violence at rates four times that of the cisgender population. We’ve seen what happens: the white supremacist violence in Charlottesville, the mass murder targeting Black shoppers in Buffalo, the coordinated disinformation campaign targeting Boston Children’s Hospital’s gender-affirming care program, which brought bomb threats and death threats against the physicians and nurses who cared for transgender youth.

And the radicalization is being aimed at the next generation. Turning Point USA, founded in 2012 by Charlie Kirk, began as a conventional conservative campus effort and devolved into something closer to a white Christian nationalist youth party. Kirk was assassinated on September 10, 2025, while speaking at a university in Utah. After his death, teachers and public employees were fired for their comments about him. People were arrested over social-media posts. The White House called for his critics to be treated as enemies. All of it made the organization he built more central to the movement. At the 2024 Conservative Political Action Conference, the right-wing activist Jack Posobiec told the crowd: “Welcome to the end of democracy. We are here to overthrow it completely.” He received applause. These people aren’t fringe actors. They’re the mainstream of a movement that controls one of the two major political parties in the United States.

I want to be careful not to say any of this from above it. I sat in those pews for years after my own agnosticism was settled, and I didn’t ask the institution a single hard question until the institution came for my son. I’m not offering that as a defense. It’s the confession of someone who looked late.

And I’ll tell you what that late looking has shown me since. I’ve sat in rooms with teachers who are quietly furious. They’ve spent whole careers learning what their students need, and now they’re calculating whether a mention of a gay figure in a civil rights lesson could cost them their job. Librarians are second-guessing every book they shelve. More and more, “parental rights” legislation requires educators to out students to potentially unsupportive parents. No specific law has to be enforced. The threat is enough to change what feels safe to say, safe to teach, safe to be. But I don’t treat that teacher’s fury as a problem to be managed. I treat it as evidence, the evidence of a professional community being told that the doubt of people who have never set foot in their classroom outranks their expertise. And I treat it as a resource.

The temptation in this fight is to treat everyone who votes for a Christian nationalist candidate as a villain. That’s lazy analysis and ruinous strategy. The committed ideologue who has examined the evidence and rejected it is a different conversation from the uncertain voter who hasn’t yet had access to honest information, and treating them as the same is counterproductive. I’ll say plainly that this charitable reading doesn’t come naturally to me. When it comes to people who have worked to erase children’s access to medical care, the anger is real. But I’ve come to believe, on the basis of evidence, that treating those voters as irredeemable simply doesn’t work.

There’s research by David Broockman and Joshua Kalla on a practice called deep canvassing. Single, thoughtful, non-judgmental conversations with voters about transgender rights, conversations in which the canvasser invited the voter to share their own story and listened without arguing, produced shifts in attitudes that were significant in size and lasted at least three months. It works because it doesn’t try to beat the certainty. It invites the voter into a different relationship with the question.

The organizational psychologist Adam Grant has written about what he calls confident humility: belief in your own capacities combined with openness to the possibility that your conclusions are wrong. The most effective change agents, Grant argues, are the most willing to revise rather than the most certain. That’s also what separates the religious tradition at its best from the religious tradition at its worst. Confident humility is what the prophets were doing. Confident certainty is what the priests supporting the king were doing. There has always been a difference, and the current movement has forgotten it.

Grant has names for the modes we slip into when our beliefs are challenged. We preach, defending the sacred. We prosecute, building the case against the other side. We politick, campaigning for the approval of whoever is watching. What we rarely do, he argues, is the fourth thing: think like scientists about our own convictions, treating them as hypotheses to test rather than treasures to guard.

I recognize all three failure modes from the inside. I’ve preached at school board meetings, prosecuted on Facebook, politicked in living rooms. The discipline this series asks of you, and of me, is the fourth mode, practiced in public, where it’s hardest.

The certainty gap is their strength. Confident humility is ours. Let’s use it.

And the story we have to offer is a better one. It goes like this: you aren’t certain, and that isn’t a failure. You don’t have all the answers, and that isn’t a weakness. You live in a world that’s more complex than the people who are frightening you are willing to admit. And in that complexity, you have neighbors whose experience of the world is different from yours, and whose dignity is no less for that difference. The community that organizes around that understanding is the community that makes democracy possible.

Sign up on this site to receive updates on the soon-to-be-published book, “Fear Me Not: The Power of Curiosity to Heal a World Addicted to Certainty.” If podcasts are your thing, please check out the podcast series of the same name.