Our family’s journey began on an Easter Sunday more than a decade ago, with a two-and-a-half-year-old who would not put on a dress.

The dress, by the way, was the same one he and his sister had worn only a couple of months earlier for a school picture. His sister was only too happy to comply. Our son wasn’t. He claimed that the dress, in spite of the pictorial evidence, wasn’t his. In fact, he refused to wear any clothes that looked “girly,” which of course presented quite the problem, since our working assumption up to that point was that we had another girl. We found an outfit that was passably gender neutral and ran with it.

In that Easter morning moment, my son had a better grasp of an engineering principle than most of the adults in the room, me included. If the model doesn’t match the data, it’s time to change the model. He was a child who knew himself better than we did, brave enough to bring it to our attention and determined enough to stick to his convictions. We just had to start listening.

What I saw that morning was a child telling the truth about his experience in the only language he had available. Nobody was performing an ideology. And what I had to learn, over time and with the help of a considerable amount of clinical evidence, was how to receive that truth honestly. This episode is about that evidence, and about the campaign that has been built to deny it.

The clinical literature on gender development in children is extensive, and it’s consistent on one point. Gender identity, your internal sense of yourself as a man, a woman, both, or neither, is present and relatively stable from early childhood. It’s distinct from gender expression and from sexual orientation, and social pressure doesn’t change it. When a child’s gender identity differs from the sex they were assigned at birth, that mismatch becomes a significant source of distress, which the clinical literature calls gender dysphoria.

But the political movement against transgender youth consistently ignores the next finding. With support, the outcomes are dramatically different. Children whose families affirm their gender identities show outcomes comparable to their cisgender peers. The variable that produces the difference is how the people around the child respond, and the child’s gender identity isn’t it.

I can tell you what that variable looked like in one house. I doubt I’ll ever be able to put into words how despondent our son had become from the dysphoria. All I can tell you is that it was a matter of life and death. After we affirmed his identity, it was like a light switch. He went from despair to a happy kid who couldn’t wait to go to school. With support, he had what every kid deserves: an ordinary childhood. That ordinariness, so hard-won and so valuable, is now the target of a coordinated legislative campaign across the United States.

The binary itself, the proposition that there are exactly two genders, that they correspond reliably to bodies, and that the correspondence is fixed at birth, is a manufactured certainty, and one of the most stubborn.

The writer Kate Bornstein made this argument in 1994, in a book called Gender Outlaw that has shaped trans and queer thought ever since. Bornstein’s claim goes well past asking that nonbinary or trans people be tolerated within the existing binary. Her claim is that the binary is the project, a coercive social fiction maintained through ritual, language, and violence, and that the people who refuse or fail to perform a legible binary gender aren’t deviants. They’re witnesses to the system’s seams.

My son arrived already on the other side of that argument, before he had the words for it. The work Bornstein did in 1994 was, in a smaller and more domestic way, the work my wife and I had to do twenty years later in our own house. We weren’t opposed. The certainty around the gender binary had simply been manufactured so effectively, and worked so deep into our thinking, that we had to overcome a knee-jerk reaction to someone who challenged it.

I think of this story and smile whenever some anti-trans legislator calls for trans-affirming parents to be prosecuted for felony child abuse, on the theory that we turned our kids trans. Have you ever tried to convince a kid to perform even the most rudimentary forms of human hygiene, like taking a bath or brushing their teeth? Convincing a child to completely transition would be as futile as trying to convince my trans son to wear a dress. And it would be as destructive as trying to convert a trans child to be cisgender.

To understand the campaign, you have to understand where it started, because it didn’t start with parents concerned about their children’s wellbeing, or with physicians uncertain about the evidence. It started with a specific political calculation made around 2014 by conservative political operatives in Houston, Texas. Public attitudes were shifting rapidly, and anti-discrimination legislation was advancing. The Houston Equal Rights Ordinance, in particular, drew the operatives’ attention because of its provisions allowing transgender people to use facilities matching their gender identity.

A local lawyer named Jared Woodfill and a local right-wing radio host, Steven Hotze, hatched what became the template for the entire national anti-trans movement. They launched a fear-mongering advertising campaign that branded transgender people as sexual predators, specifically as men who would dress as women to get into bathrooms where they could assault children. That claim had no factual basis. None. Law enforcement across states that had adopted protections for transgender students reported no increase in bathroom-related assaults. The evidence against the claim was available, unambiguous, and completely irrelevant to the campaign, because the campaign was never about evidence. It ran on fear.

The Houston experiment worked well enough to be replicated. Republican-sponsored legislation targeting transgender people spread across the country. And when the bathroom narrative proved untenable, the operatives refocused on a more vulnerable target: transgender children. Gender-affirming care, which is evidence-based medicine, got reframed as chemical castration and as sexual mutilation of children. Parents who supported their transgender children’s medical care were cast as abusers.

When I testified before the Michigan State Board of Education in 2016, the arguments against the guidance covered religious objections, bathroom safety, and parental rights. By 2022, the campaigns had added girls’ and women’s sports. Sports holds a uniquely powerful place in American culture, easily rivaling religion, and it’s governed by rules that are essentially negotiated. That made it an ideal wedge, an issue where the arguments don’t translate directly to a person’s right to exist.

But that’s exactly what the wedge is for. Sports legislation is being used as a Trojan Horse to pass laws that ban gender-affirming health care, restrict bathroom use, and forbid any mention of trans lives in public schools. The historical parallel is exact. Black athletes were once banned from competition on the basis of pseudo-scientific argument, and those same false arguments were then extended to justify the broader denial of civil and human rights.

Here you can see the mechanism of manufactured certainty at its most cynical. The genuine complexity of gender was erased and replaced with a false binary: normal children being harmed by a radical ideological agenda. Nobody discovered that binary. Somebody constructed it, and constructed it specifically because complexity doesn’t mobilize a voting base.

Now let me talk about the biology, because that’s where the manufactured certainty is easiest to test.

Ask how many people are born intersex and you’ll get answers that differ by a factor of a hundred. That sounds like a scandal, and it isn’t one. The numbers differ because the definitions differ, and the facts underneath them don’t.

One widely cited review put the figure at about 1.7 percent of births, counting every documented departure from a perfectly male or perfectly female body. A critic answered with 0.018 percent, counting only the cases where the visible anatomy can’t be sorted as male or female, or where the chromosomes and the anatomy point in different directions. The United Nations publishes the whole range: somewhere between 0.05 and 1.7 percent, depending on where you draw the line.

One number doesn’t depend on where you draw the line. Around one in every two thousand babies is born with a body different enough that a specialist gets called to the delivery room, and a decision gets made.

And I want to tell you what happened to those children.

For about four decades, American medicine had a protocol. It came from a Johns Hopkins psychologist named John Money, who argued in the nineteen-fifties that gender identity was established by rearing. Assign an infant a sex early enough, surgically and socially, don’t tell the child, and the child will grow into it.

To put it the way an engineer would, that was an untested design deployed at scale.

In 2004, William Reiner and John Gearhart published a study in the New England Journal of Medicine of sixteen genetically male children born with a severe malformation of the pelvis and genitals. Fourteen of them had been assigned female at birth, socially, legally, and surgically, and raised as girls by parents who believed they were raising girls.

Eight of the fourteen declared themselves male anyway. Some of them did it before anyone had told them anything.

Let that land, because the whole argument is in it. Those children were handed a body, a name, a wardrobe, a set of expectations, and their family’s sincere belief. More than half of them said no.

And the mirror image is just as telling. Children with complete androgen insensitivity are genetically male, but their bodies can’t read testosterone. They develop as female, and they’re raised as girls. In the entire published literature through 2004, one hundred fifty-six cases, not one changed gender.

Chromosomes didn’t predict it. In the fourteen children raised as girls, upbringing didn’t predict it. Nothing you could see from the outside predicted it.

Gender identity isn’t downstream of genitals, and it isn’t downstream of chromosomes. It’s something a person has, and reports. And the evidence says the report is the most reliable instrument we have.

The neuroscience tells the same story. Brain-imaging studies have found, across multiple independent samples, that transgender people show structural and functional characteristics more consistent with their identified gender than with the sex they were assigned at birth. The research is correlational and still developing, and gender identity can’t be reduced to a brain scan. But the findings are flatly inconsistent with the claim that a transgender identity is a misunderstanding, a mental illness, or an ideology. What they show is a stable, deeply held sense of self, and no intervention can talk a person out of it.

The clinical literature on conversion therapy is unambiguous. It doesn’t work, it causes documented harm, and every major American medical and psychological organization opposes it.

Gender identity isn’t binary either. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s 2023 Youth Risk Behavior Survey, the first nationally representative federal survey to ask, found that 3.3 percent of U.S. high school students identify as transgender, with another 2.2 percent questioning their gender identity. The Williams Institute at UCLA Law School estimates approximately 1.6 million Americans aged thirteen and older identify as transgender. Those numbers are the self-reports of human beings describing their own experience, and nobody invented them for ideological purposes.

And the medical evidence on what happens when those self-reports are taken seriously is just as unambiguous. The 2022 Tordoff study in JAMA Network Open found that access to gender-affirming care was associated with a 60 percent lower odds of depression and a 73 percent lower odds of suicidality among transgender and nonbinary youth. A Trevor Project study found that LGBTQ youth with at least one accepting adult in their life were 40 percent less likely to attempt suicide.

That’s the consensus legislation is now overriding, and it’s overriding it with manufactured certainty, since nobody has produced better evidence. By the end of 2023, twenty-two states had enacted laws restricting or banning gender-affirming care for minors. The people who passed those laws didn’t, for the most part, sit with parents of transgender children, or consult the medical organizations that had spent decades developing the standards of care. They listened to a political movement that had identified transgender children as a useful focal point for mobilizing fear.

There’s a companion fact to those laws that almost nobody mentions, and it’s the one that tells you what the laws are actually for.

For most of the last century, American medicine did to intersex children exactly what these laws claim to prevent. Surgeons assigned infants a sex and cut their bodies to match it, before the child could say a word.

Medicine has moved since then, slowly. In 2006 an international consensus conference admitted that early surgery had no controlled trials behind it. In 2017 three former U.S. Surgeons General wrote that cosmetic genital surgery on infants “is not justified absent a need to ensure physical functioning.” In 2020 a children’s hospital in Chicago became the first in America to apologize for it. Their words were: “we now know this approach was harmful and wrong.”

No American state has banned the practice.

Now hold that up against the bills. In 2023, state legislatures introduced a hundred and twenty measures to ban gender-affirming care for transgender minors, on the stated ground that children are too young to consent to irreversible interventions. Eighty-two of those bills carried explicit carve-outs permitting surgery on intersex infants.

Eighty-two out of a hundred and twenty, in the same bills, in the same session. The same legislators held, in the same document, that a fifteen-year-old who has been telling you who he is since preschool cannot consent to a reversible hormone blocker, and that an infant who has never said anything at all can be surgically assigned a sex.

You can’t call that a principle. A principle is a thing that applies when it’s inconvenient. What they wrote is a conclusion with a procedure attached, and the carve-out is the tell.

In Michigan, that conclusion came for my family. Under House Bill 6454, conservative legislators sought to make what we did, supporting the medical recommendations of pediatric endocrinologists at the University of Michigan Health System, first-degree child abuse under state law. I’m not ashamed of what we did. I’m angry that the people proposing to criminalize it weren’t. And my son now enters adulthood painfully aware that he isn’t entitled to the same individual liberties, the same civil rights, the same human rights as his peers. He has been denied care at one of the premier hospital systems in the world, because a presidential executive order to withhold federal funding from hospitals providing gender-affirming care has been effective even at an institution that has been at the forefront of such care.

This disconnect between the actual lives of transgender young people and the political construction of them as a threat is deliberate. It’s the point. At bottom, the anti-trans movement is defending a certainty, the certainty of a fixed, binary gender order, that transgender people disturb simply by existing, and the children themselves were never the subject.

Today’s attacks on transgender children use the same three instruments that sustained segregation: religion, nationalism, and fear. The specific accusations are different, grooming instead of amalgamation, gender ideology instead of race mixing, but the underlying structure is identical. In 2022, Mississippi’s attorney general signed a manifesto declaring that “when it comes to sex, separate is not inherently unequal.” In 2023, Kansas wrote the same principle into statute. That’s the logic of Plessy v. Ferguson, the case that gave us separate but equal, and they offered it as a model to follow rather than an embarrassing precedent to avoid.

I watched the manufactured certainty that my son was confused, or disordered, or going through a phase come into contact with the evidence of his actual life, and I watched that certainty fail. False certainty always fails when it meets the evidence. What you don’t know in advance is whether it fails before or after it has done catastrophic damage.

I have to be honest about one more thing. The people defending the gender-binary certainty are defending something real to them, a map of the world that tells them who they are and where they belong. They won’t surrender it easily. But they can be reached. For a long stretch of this fight, my own certainty about the other side was as closed as theirs, and that was a map I had to be willing to redraw too.

If I could get the adults who hold power in this country to have one real conversation with one of these kids, in person rather than as a policy-page hypothetical, the manufactured certainty would crumble in many of them. Because kids don’t perform certainty. They just live. And when you sit with them, you see that the certainty you’ve been sold about their lives can’t be supported.

Sign up on this site to receive updates on the soon-to-be-published book, “Fear Me Not: The Power of Curiosity to Heal a World Addicted to Certainty.” If podcasts are your thing, please check out the podcast series of the same name.