This episode starts at the very beginning. Not of my story, but at the beginning of the human nervous system. Because that’s how far back we have to go to understand our most basic instincts.
Before a human being can be curious, they have to feel safe. I don’t mean that as a slogan or as self-help. It’s closer to a law of human nature, and every argument in this series depends on it being true.
Abraham Maslow saw it plainly. His hierarchy of needs puts the most elemental needs at the base (food, water, warmth, rest) and just above them, safety. Only when those foundations hold can a person climb toward belonging, esteem, and what Maslow called self-actualization. The hierarchy has been critiqued and refined over the decades, but its core insight has held up. Before we can be wise, generous, curious, or creative, we need to feel safe. Everything else that makes us human depends on it.
I mean that literally, as a claim about how the human nervous system is built. The amygdala, the small, almond-shaped structure that serves as the brain’s primary threat-detection system, responds to perceived danger faster than the conscious mind can process information. It fires off the fight-or-flight response before the prefrontal cortex has had time to evaluate whether the threat is even real.
That wiring is adaptive. In the environment human beings evolved in, a false alarm cost almost nothing compared to missing a real one. Better to run from a shadow that turns out to be a branch than to ignore a shadow that turns out to be a predator. We’re the descendants of the ones who ran.
The problem is that this wiring was built for physical threats, and we live in a world of social and cognitive threats it handles badly. The amygdala can’t reliably tell a physical threat to your body from a social threat to your group identity, and the business of manufactured certainty exploits that fact.
When political messaging frames LGBTQ people as threats to children, or immigrants as threats to the nation, or secular education as a threat to faith, it’s activating a threat-detection system that evolved for lions. Policy disagreements never came into it. The body responds the same way either way: elevated heart rate, narrowed attention, reduced capacity for complex reasoning, heightened hostility to the out-group.
The neuroscientist Joseph LeDoux, who has spent his career studying fear, draws a distinction between fear as a first-person experience and the threat-response systems that produce it. Those systems aren’t infallible. They can be manipulated reliably—and every political strategist who has ever run a fear-based campaign has understood that. So can we, through conscious effort, interrupt the automatic threat response long enough to check whether the perceived threat corresponds to anything real? That’s supposed to be hard. It isn’t impossible, though, and if we want to govern ourselves by evidence instead of fear, we don’t get to skip it.
In plain terms, here’s the mechanism. When we look at a problem through the lens of curiosity, we route it through our prefrontal cortex instead of our amygdala. Uncertainty stops being a threat to run from and becomes a guiderail—the very thing that makes good decision-making possible.
And here’s the practical implication. Many of the people who support policies that harm LGBTQ youth, or restrict teaching about racial history, or impose religious frameworks on secular governance, aren’t acting mainly out of malice.
They’re acting out of fear: genuinely experienced, neurologically real fear, deliberately switched on by political messaging built to exploit it. That doesn’t excuse it. Fear-based governance does the same harm whether the fear is sincere or manufactured. But it changes the strategy. Confronting bad faith takes second place to patiently showing people that the perceived threat isn’t real, and that’s the only approach that produces durable change instead of the pendulum swings of fear-driven politics.
But here’s the hopeful half of the same biology. The same wiring that produces the craving for certainty also produces the capacity to examine that craving, to notice when the certainty on offer has been manufactured, and to ask for the evidence. That recursive ability—thinking about thinking—is what separates the human animal from other primates more than any specific thing we happen to know.
The philosopher Daniel Dennett called one piece of it “the intentional stance”: the capacity to model other minds, to understand behavior in terms of beliefs and desires rather than mere physical cause and effect. That capacity is what lets a parent take a child’s first-person report of their gender identity as evidence instead of writing it off as confusion, and what lets a voter weigh a political claim instead of just registering it as a threat signal. Democracy assumes citizens can do exactly that. Nobody needs technical expertise in every question. They only need to be able to tell an argument grounded in evidence from one that leans on authority or manufactured certainty.
And the whole point of manufactured certainty is to keep ordinary citizens from doing exactly that.
The strategy is straightforward. Flood the information environment so no one knows what to believe. Attack the credibility of the universities, the newsrooms, and the regulators that do the sifting on a citizen’s behalf. Reward people who sound certain and punish people who admit doubt. Do it well enough, over enough years, and you produce an electorate that no longer asks for evidence, because asking has stopped feeling like a virtue. I’m calling the resistance to all of this Scientific Rebellion. You don’t need scientific expertise to join it. The name comes from the scientific method being the best model we have for what self-government requires: putting your preferred conclusion second, and the evidence first.
The need to resolve uncertainty shapes more than how we survive. It shapes how we form groups and build our identities.
Henri Tajfel and John Turner’s work in the 1970s on social identity theory showed that humans will form in-group attachments based on even trivially arbitrary distinctions—the flip of a coin, the color of a dot. Once a group exists, members immediately favor the in-group and run down the out-group, even when the groups were created by chance. So tribalism comes mostly from the need to know who you are and where you stand, far more than from conflict over resources. The lines we draw between people turn the terrifying openness of an uncertain world into a readable map, and the people who don’t fit neatly onto that map are the ones who pay for it.
And none of that is a character flaw. The need for certainty is evolution, not a moral failing. The person who builds a wall between themselves and the unfamiliar is, at some level, frightened. Understanding that doesn’t make the wall acceptable. It does make the wall comprehensible, in ways that matter if you want to take it down.
The social psychologist Arie Kruglanski has spent decades studying what he calls the “need for cognitive closure”: the desire for a definite answer on a topic, any answer, over continued ambiguity. His research shows that this need intensifies under stress, fatigue, and threat. Under those conditions people become more authoritarian in their thinking, more hostile to information that complicates their certainties, and more likely to defer to strong leaders who project confidence.
The cocktail that intensifies the need for closure (economic anxiety, demographic change, cultural disruption, a media environment that saturates the senses with threat) describes the America of the last decade with uncomfortable precision. We’re a nation that has been made to feel uncertain, and certainty is being sold to us from every direction.
And like most addictions, this one has pushers, kingpins who profit while everyone else in the equation loses. The kingpins today are the political organizations behind massive, well-funded campaigns to instill fear and doubt about trans kids, the climate crisis, vaccines, women’s bodily autonomy, and the true history of Black and Indigenous Americans. Naming them matters, and so does naming who pays.
None of this is new. Certainty has been manufactured and sold for a long time, and you can’t understand our present moment without that history.
Take the eugenics movement of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Eugenics, the so-called science of improving human genetic stock through selective breeding and the sterilization of those deemed unfit, was mainstream science in the United States and Europe from the 1880s through the 1930s, nothing like a fringe position. It was taught in universities and endorsed by progressive politicians, including Theodore Roosevelt. And in this country it produced the forced sterilization of roughly sixty-five thousand people deemed genetically inferior, who were disproportionately poor, disabled, institutionalized, and people of color.
The manufactured certainty of eugenics wasn’t mainly religious. It was scientific in name, dressed in the language of science while lacking the substance. The research was selectively compiled and the conclusions were decided in advance. What came out was a system that used the authority of science to authorize atrocity.
I’m telling this story to show that false certainty gets produced outside religion too. I have no interest in discrediting science; its own internal mechanisms eventually caught up with eugenics and rejected it. Any framework for deciding what counts as knowledge can be corrupted when it’s put in the service of power instead of truth. The difference is the correction mechanism. Science has one, and it eventually worked. By then, though, sixty-five thousand people had already been irreversibly harmed.
The manufactured certainty of the anti-trans movement follows the same pattern as eugenics: pseudo-scientific claims about the brain, about childhood development, about the effects of gender-affirming care, built on selective citation and predetermined conclusions and scientific-sounding language in service of a political agenda. History has a verdict on the people who did the corrupted science and the people who did the honest science. It’ll have a verdict on the people doing each version now.
There’s a second historical parallel: the campaign against Galileo. His findings contradicted more than a theory. They contradicted a system of authority that had organized itself around the claim to know. I’m not singling out the Church as uniquely malign; plenty of institutions, secular and religious alike, have suppressed evidence that threatened their authority. The lesson is about the relationship between evidence and power. When evidence contradicts the people in power, they experience it as a threat to be neutralized, never as information to take on board.
That’s why the suppression of gender-affirming care, the banning of books about Black history, and the denial of climate science are one story, three instances of the same relationship. The Galileo story ended with the Church eventually acknowledging what the evidence showed. It took more than three hundred years. We don’t have three hundred years.
My training leaves me no way to think about this except in concrete terms. There’s a stone railroad bridge near my home in Dexter, Michigan, that has carried the load for more than a hundred and thirty years. Frederick Pelham designed it. He was the first African American to earn a civil engineering degree from the University of Michigan—the same college that trained me a century later. His name isn’t on the plaque. A bridge carries the load or it doesn’t, and no amount of certainty about who is permitted to be an engineer changes the arithmetic of the arch.
So we’re going to seek certainty no matter what; it’s as inevitable as hunger. The real question is whether the certainty we find will be proportioned to the evidence, or manufactured and sold by people who stand to benefit from our fear. And because the threat response runs faster than reason, the Scientific Rebellion I’m proposing can’t be only an argument. It has to be a story. It has to be a community. It has to provide what the weaponized certainty provides—belonging, identity, safety in numbers—but grounded in something true.
And here’s something the manufactured certainty has gotten right that we too often get wrong. People are emotional, and there’s nothing to correct in that. The neuroscientist Antonio Damasio has shown that people with damage to the emotional centers of the brain can’t make good decisions. They have the information. What they lack are the emotional signals that tell them which outcomes matter. Emotion and reason are partners, not enemies.
The problem is that people’s emotions are being engaged dishonestly, by manufactured threats designed to override judgment instead of informing it. Feeling things was never the problem. And telling people to stop feeling things won’t fix it. Giving them something true to feel will.
Carl Sagan understood this, and it’s why Cosmos exists. It’s why the most effective science communication has always been about revealing wonder. Wonder is the emotional signal that wakes up curiosity: the feeling of not knowing, experienced as a gift instead of a threat. I believe it’s teachable, contagious, and the only antidote to the manufactured certainty tearing this democracy apart.
There’s also a structural answer that gets left out of conversations about epistemic crisis. The anxiety and sense of threat that drive the need for manufactured certainty don’t just arise naturally. Specific economic choices produce them, in significant part. When workers lose economic security and have no safety net, their need for cognitive closure intensifies. You can’t separate defending evidence-based democracy from economic justice. I came to that slowly—through the uncomfortable recognition that my own relative security has given me a luxury in how I relate to uncertainty. I can afford to sit with open questions. Many people can’t.
The social sciences have a concept I’ve found useful here: “epistemic justice,” developed by the philosopher Miranda Fricker. It’s about who gets taken seriously as a knower, and whether people have the concepts they need to make sense of their own experience. Transgender people are routinely denied both. They’re dismissed as knowers of their own experience, and—where the book bans succeed—they’re stripped of the language they need to understand it. A ban on books about transgender lives protects no children. It’s a form of violence against their capacity to know themselves and be known.
What the Scientific Rebellion builds in response, in our schools, our legislatures, and our economy, comes later in this series. The diagnosis has to come first.
Change is possible. That’s the thing I hold onto when the news is worst. But “possible” needs unpacking, because the history of progress is a history of contingent progress, with nothing inevitable about it. Progress happened because particular people made deliberate choices that could have gone otherwise.
The history of this country is, in part, the history of manufactured certainties being taken apart. The certainty that women couldn’t vote. That Black Americans weren’t full citizens. That gay and lesbian people were mentally ill. That disabled people had nothing to contribute. Each of those was once as solid as bedrock to the people who held it. Each of them fell, because people decided to rebel and to insist, against the weight of institutional authority, that the evidence of shared humanity mattered more than manufacturing a comfortable hierarchy.
We’re at another such moment now. Meeting it begins with a set of ordinary tools: curiosity, evidence, critical thinking. They aren’t complicated, and you already own them. They ask only one thing of you, the willingness to use them. That’s where we go next.
Sign up on this site to receive updates on the soon-to-be-published book, “Fear Me Not: The Power of Curiosity to Heal a World Addicted to Certainty.” If podcasts are your thing, please check out the podcast series of the same name.


