This episode is about a particular kind of claim. The kind that cannot be argued with.
You can argue with a policy decision. You can’t argue with a divine mandate. That’s the fundamental difference between evidence-based governance and faith-based governance. One is, in principle, open to debate, revision, and reversal, and the other is closed to all three. The difference between a law that can be challenged and a law that can’t is the distance between democracy and theocracy.
I want to be exact about what I am and am not saying, because our public conversation constantly collapses two very different things. I’m an agnostic, not an atheist. I don’t know whether there is a God, or some form of transcendence the word God gestures toward, and I distrust the certainty of anyone, believer or atheist, who claims that they do.
I have no quarrel with faith held humbly, with the tentativeness appropriate to questions that transcend human knowledge, faith that produces a commitment to human dignity rather than a defense of hierarchy. My quarrel is with the weaponization of faith: the political use of religious certainty to override the rights of people who don’t share it.
The history of Christianity in America is the history of one tension, between the prophetic tradition that calls the powerful to account for their treatment of the vulnerable and the priestly tradition that legitimates existing power by blessing it. Both are present in the Christian scriptures. Jemar Tisby, in The Color of Compromise, documents how the mainstream of white American Christianity chose the priestly over the prophetic, again and again. It accommodated slavery rather than opposing it. It accommodated segregation rather than opposing it.
That isn’t the whole of the tradition. The prophetic strand has been alive throughout, in the abolitionist clergy, in the civil rights movement, in liberation theology. Some of the most important work of the civil rights movement was done by deeply religious people whose faith drove a courageous commitment to justice.
I’m not a theologian, and I can’t settle the internal debate within Christianity about which strand is more authentic. What I can do, what any honest observer can do, is note that the political agenda of Christian nationalism is causing specific, documentable harm to specific, identifiable people. And that “because God says so” isn’t a sufficient justification for that harm in a pluralistic democracy. The claim to speak for God is a human claim, made by human beings with human interests, and it’s subject to the same standard of evidence as any other claim about the world.
I’m not asking believers to abandon their faith. I’m saying that faith, however sincere, is not fact. And the laws governing all of us have to be grounded in evidence all of us can examine, rather than in supernatural claims only the faithful can access.
With that said, the record of what happens when a claim is placed beyond argument is clear.
For millennia, the most powerful institutions in the Western world were religious institutions. The rules of law were said to originate directly from God, and were therefore presented as incontestable. Of course, they were interpreted and modified as the men in power saw fit.
In the fifteenth century, the Catholic Church became the first global institution to formally authorize the enslavement of non-Christians. The Doctrine of Discovery was issued in a series of papal decrees beginning in 1452. Pope Nicholas the Fifth issued the decrees for Africa. Pope Alexander the Sixth issued the decree for the Americas, in 1493. They declared that European Christian monarchies had the God-ordained right to conquer, claim, and enslave the peoples of any lands not already ruled by Christians.
That doctrine authorized the invasion of the Americas, the destruction of Indigenous civilizations, the seizure of their lands, the forcible conversion or enslavement of their populations. The United States Supreme Court cited it as legal precedent as recently as 2005. The Catholic Church didn’t formally repudiate it until 2023.
Nobody presented the Doctrine of Discovery as a policy decision. It was presented as the will of God, and that is where its power came from.
The thread running through that history is certainty. Malice was certainly present, but malice isn’t the thread. Certainty is: the certainty that the order of things was natural and God-ordained, and not for fallible human reason to question. That certainty served a function. It resolved the cognitive dissonance of otherwise decent people who found themselves taking part in systems of extraordinary cruelty. It provided exactly the psychological service that false certainty always provides, comfort against a moral complexity that would otherwise be unbearable.
Religion has no monopoly on the mechanism. The eugenics movement I described in Chapter One placed its certainty beyond argument by dressing it as science. The Soviet state did the same to genetics, and I’ll come back to that in a later episode. What the religious version adds is a claim that can’t be tested even in principle. That’s why it has been the most durable version, and why it’s the one to watch most closely.
Because it isn’t safely in the past. The same logic is operating right now, quietly and institutionally, inside the medical system most Americans turn to in a crisis.
Four of the ten largest American hospital chains are now Catholic. As Catholic-affiliated hospitals have expanded, they’ve systematically restricted access to reproductive health services: contraception, sterilization, miscarriage management, end-of-life care. The directives governing this restriction are issued by the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, an all-male body, and they carry the force of theological certainty. The bishops’ Ethical and Religious Directives require that whatever comes under the control of a Catholic institution “must be operated in full accord with the moral teaching of the Catholic Church.” Theological certainty has no mechanism for weighing evidence about who gets harmed.
The American Medical Association’s ethics council has documented the consequences. It describes reports of conflict over sterilization and the management of miscarriage. It warns that restricted access “can have a disproportionate impact on poor women, and women in rural areas where religiously affiliated institutions are the only providers of care.”
Think of a woman in rural Michigan whose only hospital within fifty miles is Catholic-affiliated, arriving in the emergency room with an incomplete miscarriage. A physician trained at one of the great research universities of the world, bound by the Hippocratic oath, aware of exactly what needs to happen. A set of directives written by an all-male body of bishops, none of whom will ever be in that room, that says it cannot.
That’s what it looks like when a claim you can’t argue with is allowed to govern evidence-based practice. That’s what every freedom-loving American should fear. Conservative politicians endlessly insist the thing to fear is trans kids and wokeness. This is the thing to fear.
American law is moving along the same track. One of the quietest and most consequential shifts in American civil rights law has been the steady expansion of religious exemptions. The Religious Freedom Restoration Act, passed in 1993, was originally written to protect minority religious communities from laws that didn’t anticipate them. A long string of lawsuits has since turned it into the legal mechanism by which religious organizations and individuals claim exemption from the civil rights laws the rest of us have to follow.
The Supreme Court’s 2014 decision in Burwell versus Hobby Lobby established that closely held corporations can claim religious exemptions from generally applicable laws requiring them to provide contraceptive coverage to employees. The court’s 2023 decision in 303 Creative versus Elenis held that a web design company offering services to the public could refuse to design wedding websites for same-sex couples. The owner’s objection was religious, but the court ruled on free-speech grounds: the websites were her own expressive work, and the state could not compel it.
Add it up and you get a two-tiered civil rights system. LGBTQ people and women have formal legal protections, and an expanding set of religious exemptions that hollow them out. The protections exist on paper, and the exemptions do the work in practice.
The legal scholars Douglas NeJaime and Reva Siegel call claims like these “complicity-based conscience claims”: objections to what other people are permitted to do, rather than to anything the believer must do. In each case, the religious freedom claim is made in the name of protecting sincere belief. In each case, the actual effect is to use the law to impose the costs of that belief on people who don’t share it. That’s the structural logic of faith-based governance. The beliefs of some get to define the rights available to others.
The founders weren’t naive about this. They had watched European states make a mess of theocracy. The Establishment Clause and the protection of free exercise were fundamentally the same instrument: religious freedom protected, without being weaponized into the freedom to govern other people’s lives by anyone’s particular faith. We’re watching that distinction collapse.
There is a response, and it has to work at several levels. Pass laws, like the Equality Act, which would extend federal civil rights protections to LGBTQ people, and the Women’s Health Protection Act, which would establish a federal right to abortion. Both have been blocked repeatedly in the Senate. Laws like these provide explicit protections that aren’t subject to the same religious-exemption logic. Elect judges who understand the balance the founders actually struck. And in every conversation, refuse to accept “because my religion says so” as a sufficient reason to deny equal treatment to a neighbor, a customer, or a student.
Then there’s Project 2025, the Heritage Foundation’s blueprint for a second Trump administration. Unlike most political documents, it states its premises openly. Its vision of the good society is explicitly theological: a society built around “God’s design for humanity,” with family structure, gender roles, and sexual expression all ordered according to a specific interpretation of Christian teaching. The manufactured doubt at its heart is the claim that this program represents a return to natural or traditional values rather than the imposition of a specific ideological agenda. But there’s nothing natural about the natural order it proposes to restore. It’s a historically contingent arrangement of power, made to look natural through the cultural authority of a particular religious tradition.
Every expansion of rights in American history has felt transgressive to someone. The abolition of slavery, the enfranchisement of women, the recognition of same-sex marriage: each felt, to the people defending the existing order, like a violation of something sacred. Each was, in fact, the correction of a historical error.
I’m an engineer. In engineering we have a concept called the single point of failure, a component whose failure brings down the whole system. Faith-based governance is a single point of failure for democratic accountability. When the basis for a law is supernatural authority, there’s no mechanism for accountability. You can’t argue with God. You can’t subject God to peer review. You can’t vote God out. A government that derives its authority from God is accountable only to the intermediaries who claim to speak for God, and in practice those intermediaries line up remarkably well with the interests of people already in power.
A democracy that leans on the unquestioned moral authority of one reading of one religious tradition has a single point of failure of exactly this kind. It works as long as the authority goes unquestioned. It stops working the moment the authority is challenged, because it was never designed for that.
There is good news, and it’s this: the dissenters within institutional religion have always been there. The Catholic nuns who organized labor unions. The liberation theologians of Latin America who insisted that the Gospel requires the preferential option for the poor. The priests and ministers who marched at Selma. The congregations that affirm transgender dignity today.
What unites them is a specific theological claim, rather than any liberal political agenda: that authentic faithfulness requires extending moral concern to the people the comfortable certainties of the institutional church have excluded. I respect that faith without reservation. Far from being my enemy, it’s my ally. These believers have already done the internal work of separating faith as personal inspiration from faith as political domination. They know the difference from the inside.
The humble, welcoming kind of faith is the kind this series stands with. The other kind, the claim that cannot be argued with, installed as law, is the one I’m asking you to recognize and refuse.
Sign up on this site to receive updates on the soon-to-be-published book, “Fear Me Not: The Power of Curiosity to Heal a World Addicted to Certainty.” If podcasts are your thing, please check out the podcast series of the same name.


